What to Do When Carnivore Stalls
The Early Wins and the Unexpected Stall
When people first start carnivore, the results can feel nothing short of miraculous. Weight often drops quickly, inflammation eases, digestion calms, cravings disappear, skin clears, and energy skyrockets. Many report sleeping more deeply, experiencing fewer autoimmune flares, and finally feeling like their body is working with them rather than against them. For a time, it can feel like every system is moving in the right direction.
But as the weeks turn into months, some notice that the momentum slows. The scale may stop moving. Joint pain that had vanished might creep back. Digestion can feel sluggish again, or sleep isn’t as restorative as it was at the start. This is what many describe as a stall. It can be discouraging, but a stall does not mean carnivore has stopped working. It is simply feedback — your body’s way of saying it has adapted to your current approach and needs refinement to keep progressing.
Energy Intake: Fueling Healing
One of the most common reasons for a stall is under-eating. Carnivore naturally suppresses appetite, especially in the beginning, and many people unintentionally fall into eating less than their body requires over time. This can slow fat loss, but it can also interfere with sleep, thyroid function, and immune resilience. Healing requires fuel. If the body perceives famine, it will conserve energy instead of repairing and rebuilding. A short period of tracking intake can reveal whether you are consistently providing the energy your body actually needs.
Timing and Meal Frequency
Meal timing and frequency also play a role. Some thrive on one or two large meals per day, while others find that spreading intake into three or four meals supports steadier energy, better digestion, and more restful sleep. What feels freeing at first can become a stressor if it raises cortisol or keeps digestion overworked. For some, a long fast leaves them wired and unable to sleep; for others, constant grazing leaves them bloated and fatigued. Adjusting timing — whether by eating earlier in the day, allowing longer breaks between meals, or shifting food toward the morning — can often make the difference between stalled progress and renewed momentum.
Protein and Fat Ratios
Another factor is the balance between protein and fat. While carnivore provides both, the ratio matters depending on your goals. Too much fat can stall weight loss, while too little can crash hormones and leave you exhausted. Excessively high protein without enough fat can be harsh on digestion or trigger restless nights, while an overemphasis on fat may leave you under-fueled for building or preserving lean mass. The right ratio is not the same for everyone, and sometimes simply leaning toward a different cut of meat for a season can restart progress across multiple areas of health.
Stress, Sleep, and Lifestyle
Lifestyle factors outside of diet are also critical. Poor sleep, chronic stress, overtraining, or exposures to toxins and mold can all override the benefits of dietary change. Many times what looks like a diet stall is actually a recovery stall. If sleep is shallow, stress is unrelenting, or sunlight and movement are lacking, no amount of dietary perfection will push the body into deeper healing. Examining these areas honestly is often what reveals the hidden barrier.
Nutrients Beyond Macros
Nutrient density plays a role as well. Carnivore can provide nearly everything the body needs, but it requires variety. Eating only muscle meats can leave gaps in certain vitamins and minerals needed for thyroid function, immunity, and repair. Organ meats, marrow, broths, and a rotation of different cuts offer a broader spectrum of nutrients that can fill in the missing pieces. Similarly, attention to electrolytes such as sodium, potassium, and magnesium can dramatically affect sleep quality, energy levels, and digestion. Healing is not only about the macronutrients of protein and fat but also about the smaller cofactors that keep every system running smoothly.
Progress Isn’t Always Linear
Finally, it is important to redefine what progress looks like. A stall on the scale may not reflect what is happening internally. Many people lose fat while gaining lean mass, which can make weight appear unchanged while their body composition is improving. Others see a pause in symptom relief as the body consolidates progress before moving to the next stage of healing. Gut repair, autoimmune remission, and sleep restoration often happen in waves — periods of rapid improvement, followed by plateaus, and then another leap forward. Looking only at the scale can miss the larger picture of what is unfolding beneath the surface.
When Some Choose to Go Animal-Based
For some, strict carnivore feels best long term. For others, after a season of healing, they find that expanding into a broader “animal-based” approach works better for their body and goals. This doesn’t mean carnivore failed them — it means their needs shifted. Animal-based eating still centers meat, eggs, and dairy, but allows flexibility for those who want to test what else they can tolerate, including some nontoxic plant foods. Some explore this path for digestive variety, others for athletic performance, and others simply for the long-term sustainability of their lifestyle. The important thing is that this choice is always intentional, not reactionary. Some stay strictly carnivore forever; some adapt toward animal-based eating. Both paths can be powerful when they are aligned with the individual’s biology and goals.
The Bigger Picture
When carnivore stalls, it is an invitation to step back and reassess. Why did you start in the first place? Was it weight loss, autoimmune relief, mental clarity, or better sleep? Sometimes a stall signals that the initial goal has been addressed, and now the body is ready for the next refinement. Clarifying your deeper “why” can transform frustration into focus and turn a stall into a checkpoint rather than a dead end.
Final Thoughts
In the end, stalls are not a sign that your body is broken or that carnivore has failed. They are your body’s way of communicating that it has adapted and needs a subtle shift to keep moving forward. By reevaluating energy intake, adjusting meal timing, refining protein and fat ratios, addressing lifestyle stressors, filling micronutrient gaps, and broadening your definition of success, you can break through the plateau and continue toward deeper healing. Carnivore is not just a diet; it is a tool for rebuilding your biology.
But sometimes, the right next step isn’t obvious from the inside. That’s where having expert guidance matters. I work with clients who want to break through stalls—whether that means dialing in their carnivore approach more precisely, or thoughtfully transitioning into a broader animal-based lifestyle that supports long-term energy, healing, and resilience. No two bodies are the same, and the best results come from knowing exactly how to adapt when progress slows.
If you’re ready to get unstuck and discover what your body truly needs to keep moving forward, I’d love to help you take that next step.
References
Barnes, B. (1976). Hypothyroidism: The Unsuspected Illness. Harper & Row.
Amati, F., et al. (2011). "Skeletal muscle triglycerides, diacylglycerols, and ceramides in insulin resistance: another paradox in endurance-trained athletes?" Diabetes.
Pontzer, H. (2017). Burn: New Research Blows the Lid Off How We Really Burn Calories. Penguin Press.
Minger, D. (2019). In Defense of Low-Fat: A Call for Some Evolutionary Perspective. Blog essay.
Peat, R. (2006). “Thyroid, Insomnia, and Metabolism.” Ray Peat Newsletter.
Danforth, E. (1979). "Diet and thyroid hormone production." The New England Journal of Medicine.
